Sponsored
I did not think of myself as a subscription box person. My dog Milo is not particularly difficult to shop for. He likes squeaky things, he likes treats, and he likes destroying both as efficiently as possible. I figured I had his needs covered. Then a friend mentioned she had been doing BarkBox for almost a year and her dog had started sitting by the front door in the days before it arrived, and something about that detail stuck with me. I signed up that night, mostly out of curiosity.
That was eight months ago. I have renewed every single time. Here is what I have figured out.
The Box:
Every month, BarkBox delivers a themed box sized to your dog: two toys, two bags of all-natural treats, and a chew. The theming is the part that sounds like a gimmick until you actually experience it. Each box is built around a single creative concept and everything inside (the toys, the treats, the packaging) works together. The month I got the “Chewrassic Bark” dinosaur theme, Milo received a plush pterodactyl that he ran victory laps with around my apartment for twenty minutes before settling in to destroy it with great seriousness. The following month was a flower shop theme. The month after that, a space explorer. It sounds silly. It is, in fact, not silly at all. It makes every box feel like a genuine event rather than a restocking.
“I kept waiting for the novelty to wear off. Eight months in, it has not. If anything, I look forward to the box almost as much as Milo does.”
The treats are where I noticed the biggest practical difference from what I had been buying before. BarkBox treats are all-natural, made in the U.S. and Canada, with no fillers, no wheat, no soy, no corn. Milo has a mild sensitivity to certain proteins and I flagged it at signup. Every box since has been adjusted accordingly, without me having to think about it. That alone would have been worth it. The fact that Milo reacts to these treats like I have offered him something sacred is just a bonus.
What comes in every BarkBox:
Two themed toys designed exclusively for BarkBox, two bags of all-natural treats made in the U.S. and Canada, one meaty chew, and occasional bonus items. Everything customized to your dog’s size and any dietary needs you flag at signup.
The Ritual:
My friend was right about the delivery-day behavior, by the way. I noticed it around month three with Milo. He is not a dog who gets worked up about much. He sleeps through the doorbell. He is unimpressed by most things I try to excite him with. But in the days before the BarkBox arrives, he starts making his patrol route between the living room and the front door. He does not do this for any other delivery. I have no scientific explanation for how he knows. He just knows.
What I have come to appreciate is that BarkBox gave him something to look forward to on a predictable schedule, and it created a ritual that belongs to both of us. When the box arrives I sit on the floor and he investigates each item in a specific order I have never been able to predict. The toys first, then the treats, then whatever else is in there. He has a system. I have learned not to interrupt it.
“It created a ritual that belongs to both of us. That sounds like a small thing. It is not a small thing.”
BarkBox also backs their toys with a Scout’s Honor guarantee: if your dog destroys a toy before the month is out, they will replace it. Milo has tested this once. It worked exactly as advertised, with no back and forth, no skepticism. For a dog who treats plush toys as engineering problems to be solved, that guarantee is not a small detail.
The Verdict
I went in skeptical and came out a convert, which is not usually how I describe my relationship with subscription services. The theming makes it feel like a gift every time. The treat quality is genuinely better than what I was buying on my own. The ritual it built between me and Milo was something I did not know I was signing up for and am now not willing to give up. If you have been on the fence, I would run the experiment. Milo would tell you the same thing if he could talk, and given how he behaves on delivery day, I think his position is fairly clear.